Added: Jan 23, 2008
From: InReasonWeTrust
Duration: 4:59
Phleg-mat-ic (adj.): (1) Of or relating to phlegm.(2) Having a calm, sluggish temperament; unemotional. "Combating phlegmatic atheism" For years, I prided myself as apathetic when it came to my religious beliefs - it was difficult overcoming the mental baggage of years of indoctrination, and I left my teenage deconversion trauma somewhat disoriented and jaded by the shear enormity of the step I took. Because the process tore at me, I feared how sensitive the subject might be to others, and being the nice guy that I am, I did not want to cause my family or friends undue stress. Yet all the while, being a closet disbeliever led to resentment. Everybody made assumptions and my insights into the meaning of life, and the fundamental nature of my life, went unappreciated by those who claimed to know me. Those incessant little assumptions: The religious season cards that naively identified you as a member of God's Team of Believers; or the kindly stranger that asks for God to bless you—even though it was her ungodly overdose of perfume that set you sneezing; or those majority-polling politicians that insist that everyone must know that they are part of Your supposed In-club of Majority Believers. When it comes to any belief, it's particularly easy to keep things private if you want to. Unless you go public—on the Internet or Television— religious family members may hint or inquire about what you believe, but cop out replies are easy. Mine was, "I don't believe in institutional religion" (the age-old, "I'm spiritual, but not orthodox" argument) or eventually, "I'm staying open minded, but I think I'm probably agnostic or maybe I'm just ambivalently unsure about all or part of it." Rather than hide your beliefs, there is often value in being boldly visible; to family, friends, coworkers and even strange mal-odorous woman who bless you on the street. Atheistic philosophies are exciting. Why aren't we more evangelical? What is the value of PASSIONATE skepticism and religious dissent? First, given the difficulty many have in overcoming their childhood indoctrination, there is a clear need for strong and exciting role models. Unlike life in the pre-webbed world, when role models were unavailable, the Internet offers many models for alternative perspectives. So foremost, being a positive and enthusiastic atheistic provides support for those struggling with their newfound disbeliefs. Second, there are ever-present affronts to freedom of thought and to equality that erode the foundations of democratic institutions, and these should make you mad. Too often, disbelievers comprise a shy and silent minority, and the shy and silent tend to be shy and silent when repressed. Finally, the alternatives to religious explanations are exciting. Embracing the here-and-now instead of the myth of eternal consciousness alters the value and meaning of life. I became more deeply bonded to life on earth and appreciative of my own life. I am a stronger person for becoming more skeptical while being welded to the value of science. I am constantly stunned by its power of discovery. Overcoming phlegmatic disbelief requires a strong dose of passion. For me, that passion comes from sharing my insights and experiences and from my queerly Puritanical intolerance of intolerance and faith in the individual. There must always be room for religion, but for me, a good and livable society needs loud and passionate voices of doubt.
Channel: People
Tags: atheism atheist closet passionate
Rating: 4.58 (36 ratings) Views: 760' favoriteCount='6 Comments: 13
pandstar Says:
Jan 23, 2008 - Bravo! Could be your best vid yet! Your passion for reason and science comes through loud and clear.
Katalyzt Says:
Jan 23, 2008 - Interesting... By definition; I am a "phlegmatic atheist", but only in the since that outside of YT, I do not initiate theological conversation and/or advertise my atheism until asked... Katalyzt
kurtilein3 Says:
Jan 23, 2008 - this video is really great, i completely agree with you. here on the internet, different religions clash. and in between are the antitheists, the outspoken skeptics. and some of them are good role-models: highly educated, rational, intelligent, well-spoken.
deBeuk Says:
Jan 23, 2008 - Great video, and good to see you posting one again. I'm a skeptic, and member of a local skeptic's society. I've given talks about skepticism, atheism, fundamentalism and ID/creationism. I try to refute fundamentalist and creationist nonsense here on youtube. I'm very vocal when I hear someone make an ignorant statement regarding atheism or agnosticism, no matter where I am. I agree completely, people should be more vocal.
hellshade2 Says:
Jan 23, 2008 - i tend to walk the line between agnostic and atheism though i lean toward atheism,if that's possible or logical i'm not sure :) phlegmatic it seems is a fair description. thxs for sharing your thoughts here irwt :)
hellshade2 Says:
Jan 23, 2008 - i was raised christian, had the baptism,communion and confirmation. but by the time i was like 12-13 my mother never made me go to church. she'd ask if i wanted to go and if i did'nt she did not force the issue.i think she was letting me decide for myself.....
hellshade2 Says:
Jan 23, 2008 - btw it's nice to see you back irwt. hope everything is going good for you at your new locale and with your new job :)
InReasonWeTrust Says:
Jan 23, 2008 - Thanks for the feedback.
Clemburke1111 Says:
Jan 25, 2008 - InReason,,why did you move to NC?
InReasonWeTrust Says:
Jan 26, 2008 - Job. Life. Wildflowers.
ronwilliams753 Says:
Jan 27, 2008 - Thanks. I agree with all of that. Have just found your site, so will be exploring your other videos.
worldlystone Says:
Feb 14, 2008 - HELL YES!
Ashiman12 Says:
Feb 27, 2008 - Try as I might, both organized religion and atheism left me apathetic and uninterested. Therefore, I pursue spirituality on my own terms. The way I see it, life is a process of growth. If atheism promotes growth with you, then all power to you! In the end, it's up to each individual person to weigh their options and come to their own conclusions, even if we disagree with those conclusions. I, for one, have no need to inflict my understanding on others just because I find them meaningful.
captainmutiny Says:
Mar 10, 2008 - I think this is brilliant. If every atheist speaks up, we can come closer to abolishing the hold of religion on our society.
Clemburke1111 Says:
Jan 23, 2008 - I was lucky, I grew up in Cocoa beach where Atheism Is another norm,,due the the men and women that worked for the Space program,,,but religion was there too, but not as Vocal.I come from an Atheist family.